See how proposed budget cuts will impact the services you care about.
FY13 ENACTED STATE BUDGET SUMMARY
On March 30, 2012, the
New York State legislature passed the final pieces of the fiscal year 2012-13
(FY13) budget for the year that began April 1, 2012. The budget totaled $132.6 billion, in keeping
with the Governor’s promise to keep overall state spending growth below two
percent. Both education and Medicaid spending were allowed four percent
increases as agreed to last year.
The State’s improved
financial situation is due in large part to the work invested by HSC and partners
across the state to reform the Personal Income Tax this past fall and winter, which
provided $1.9 billion in additional funding to begin to make restorations and
avoid further devastating cuts. The projected deficit
for FY14 is only $1 billion, a significant improvement compared to previous
recent outyear deficits.
Overall,
the FY13 budget had mixed results for human services. While we enjoyed some
important restorations, we have to put this in context of the nearly one
billion in direct service cuts and an estimated 27,000 jobs lost in the last
two years, as well as how human services faired in comparison to new
investments in infrastructure and economic development and restorations in education
which both saw about $1 billion in this budget compared to the approximately $150
million in human service restorations. Nonprofit providers were also put
on the defensive against the threat of COLA elimination and executive
compensation and administrative rate caps.
ADMINISTRATIVE POLICIES
COLA
Among
the restorations, HSC successfully lobbied against the elimination of the human
services cost-of-living adjustment (COLA). Although delayed to FY14, the
multi-year deal will be continued without the inclusion of language regarding
meeting new performance standards. This is a significant victory that protects
the availability of the COLA in the future and does not tie earned salary
adjustments to outcomes for this deserving workforce which hasn’t seen a COLA
in what will now be four years as other operational costs such as health
insurance, rents and utilities continue to rise.
Executive
Compensation & Administrative Overhead Caps
Executive
Compensation and Administrative Overhead regulations are not part of the final
budget; the Governor will implement changes through his January 18th,
Executive Order. The Governor’s Executive Order places a $199,000 cap on State
reimbursement of executive compensation, and also limits administrative
overhead reimbursement to 25% in FY13, decreasing to 20% in FY14, and 15% in
FY15 and beyond. State agencies are responsible for promulgating regulations to
meet the requirements of the Executive Order.
Proposed
regulations are expected to be issued on April 18 (this date was set by the
Executive Order), and will appear in the Federal Register a few weeks following
submission. At that time, there will be a public comment period and then the
final regulations will be issued. Currently, they expect the regulations to be
in place for January 2013.
HSC leadership met with Jeremy Creelan, Counsel to the Governor,
who is heading up the effort early this week, and will continue to provide
updates to our membership as the regulations move forward.
Efficiencies
The Governor and
legislature reached a compromise to allow the administration flexibility to
expedite government consolidation and streamlining. The “interchangeability”
provisions give the state the authority to move certain funds between state
agencies that will save money in back office functions such as business
services, information technology and call centers. This will allow the state to
move functions from one state agency to another to improve efficiency, ensure
better performance, and reduce costs. The transfers will not be used to alter
or shift programmatic functions of the agencies. Additionally, local governments and
not-for-profits will be able to participate in the new centralized contracting
process for goods and services through the Office of General Services.
The Legislature also accepted the
Governor’s proposal to facilitate the integration of physical and behavioral
health services “by enabling two or more of the Commissioners of Department of
Health, Office of Mental Health, Office of Alcoholism and Substance Abuse
Services and OPWDD to waive duplicative regulatory requirements.”
HSC continues to work
with the administration to give the provider perspective on these reforms and had
lobbied the legislature to support initiatives that will create efficiencies in
the contracting process such as the single statewide application, a single
statewide contract, and the Statewide Grants Management Portal; providing
not-for-profits and state agencies a single web-based platform.
OTHER GENERAL AREAS OF INTEREST
Member Items
Unfortunately, the return
of new legislative member item funding was not included in the FY13 budget
after early support from Speaker Silver. Last provided in FY10, many
nonprofits across the state had relied on this funding to provide vital
services to communities when other sources of funding were not available. However,
news reports continue regarding old, unspent discretionary funds being provided
on limited bases over the past couple years. HSC plans to continue advocacy for
the return of new member items next year, with an improved transparency process,
to support neighborhood
initiatives that assist those most in need.
2-1-1
The 2-1-1 statewide information and
referral service saves state and local government money by helping people
navigate the complex world of public and private human service agencies. A well-trained staff working with a
comprehensive data base of regional services helps people find the right agency
to call the first time, allowing state and local government staff to spend more
of their time assisting callers who are eligible for their services. Though
advocates asked for $3.28 million in state support for 2-1-1, which is
partially supported by United Ways, local governments, and other private
sources, $1 million was provided in the final budget.
PROGRAM MODIFICATIONS
Below are programs which
have been restored, seen increases, or in rare cases, reductions, in the FY13
Enacted Budget. Programs not mentioned below, are level funded at the same
amount from FY12 or had not been proposed for modification.
OFFICE OF CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES (OCFS)
Close to Home
The FY13 budget includes
the Governor’s new Close to Home Initiative that intends to reduce crime,
improve outcomes for youth and their communities, and increase the efficiency
of the juvenile justice facility system. Close to Home allows New York City
(NYC) to take responsibility for the care of lower risk youth who come from the
City. While youth committed to secure level juvenile justice facilities will
continue to be in State custody and facilities, NYC youth currently in State
non-secure and limited secure facilities will be transferred to
City-administered programs and facilities. Youth from NYC needing this level of
care going forward will be in the custody of NYC and served in settings that
are appropriate for their educational, mental health, substance abuse and other
service needs. NYC will take over this responsibility from the State with
regard to youth in non-secure placements no sooner than September 1, 2012, and
for youth in limited secure placements no earlier than April 1, 2013, following
the approval by the State of comprehensive implementation plans for each level
of care.
The OCFS
State-operated juvenile justice system capacity will be reduced by
approximately 320 beds and after care slots over the next two years (140 beds in
FY13 and 180 beds in FY14) to reflect the impact of the initiative to place NYC
youth in NYC-administered programs nearer to their homes. The associated savings
to the state are estimated to be $4.5 million in FY13 and $27 million in FY14.
Child Welfare Funding
The enacted budget maintains the state
reimbursement rate for preventive services at 65% in statute, even though the
actual reimbursement rate will remain at 62% for FY13. While largely
symbolic, this language allows the state to return to 65% as the economy
improves.
Child
Care Subsidies
The
Executive budget had proposed using $93 million in state funds to offset the
loss of federal dollars to child care subsidies in FY13. The legislature added
$2 million in TANF funds to the final budget. The final funding break down is
$208.05 million in OCFS general funds and $324.28 million in TANF funds for a
total of $532.3 million in child care subsidies.
|
OCFS Programs (in millions) |
FY11
Total Budget Amount |
FY12
Total Budget Amount |
FY13
Total Budget Amount |
FY13
Add/Cut |
|
2-1-1 |
$0.000 |
$0.000 |
$0.750 |
$0.750 |
|
Caseworker Caseload Ratios Funding* |
$1.510 |
$0.757 |
$0.757 |
$0.000 |
|
Center for Alt. Sentencing & Employment** |
$0.000 |
$0.000 |
$2.000 |
$2.000 |
|
Child Advocacy Centers |
$5.230 |
$5.229 |
$5.979 |
$0.750 |
|
Community Reinvestment |
$0.000 |
$4.000 |
$1.750 |
-$2.250 |
|
NYS Alliance of Boys and Girls Clubs** |
$0.000 |
$0.000 |
$0.750 |
$0.750 |
|
Runaway and Homeless Youth |
$2.210 |
$2.360 |
$2.575 |
$0.215 |
|
Safe Harbour |
$3.000 |
$0.000 |
$1.500 |
$1.500 |
|
Settlement Houses* |
$0.900 |
$0.450 |
$0.450 |
$0.000 |
|
Youth Dev. & Delinquency Prev. /Special Del. Prevention (YDDP/SDPP) |
$28.240 |
$14.100 |
$15.400 |
$1.300 |
|
Total |
|
|
|
$5.015 |
*Caseload Ratios and
Settlement House funding had been recommended for elimination in the Executive
proposal. In addition to the $450,000 in OCFS funding for Settlement Houses, $1M
is added in TANF funding.
**New Funding in FY13.
OFFICE OF TEMPORARY AND DISABILITY ASSISTANCE (OTDA)
Takeover of Administration of the SSI Supplementation
Program
The
FY13 Budget accepts the State takeover of the administration of the State
Supplemental Security Income (SSI) supplementation program, which was
administered by the Federal Social Security Administration at significant cost
to the State. The state plans to investment in new IT systems and staff and
expects to save over $90 million annually after full implementation.
|
OTDA Programs (in millions) |
FY11 Total Budget Amount |
FY12 Total Budget Amount |
FY13 Total Budget Amount |
FY13 Cut/Add |
|
ESL/Adult Basic Education Class* |
|
|
|
$0.250 |
|
NYS Supportive Housing Program** |
$20.160 |
$19.730 |
$20.080 |
$1.500 |
|
NYS Solutions to End Homelessness** |
$8.175 |
$7.520 |
$7.870 |
$1.500 |
|
Disability Advocacy Program*** |
$0.483 |
$0.098 |
$0.348 |
$0.250 |
|
Total |
|
|
|
$3.500 |
*State
Education Department Adult Literacy Education (ALE) and Employment Preparation Education (EPE) funds
typically support ESL/ABE programs. The final budget also increases ALE by $1 million for a total of
$5.293 million in FY13.
** In prior years, many
individual supportive housing and homeless service programs have been combined
to become NYSSHP and STEHP. Therefore, FY11 figures shown are an estimate of
the former programs.
***DAP
was funded with TANF dollars in FY11 and FY12.
See Department of Health
section for additional supportive housing investments.
TEMPORARY AID TO NEEDY FAMILIES (TANF)
Public Assistance Grant Increase
The
enacted budget provides the final 10 percent increase in the public assistance
grant in full, rather than split over FY13 and FY14, as proposed in the
Executive budget. The last of a three part phase in will be provided in two installments in FY13 on July 1, 2012 and
October 1, 2012, for a total of $16 million that will include $12 million in
TANF funding and $4 million in general funds.
|
TANF Programs (in millions) |
FY11
Total Budget Amount |
FY12
Total Budget Amount |
FY13
Total Budget Amount |
FY13
Add/Cut |
|
ACCESS- Welfare to Careers |
$0.250 |
$0.250 |
$0.800 |
$0.550 |
|
Adv. Tech Training & Info Networking (ATTAIN) |
$7.000 |
$0.000 |
$3.000 |
$3.000 |
|
Advantage Afterschool |
$11.213 |
$0.500 |
$0.500 |
$0.000 |
|
Bridge |
$1.000 |
$0.102 |
$0.102 |
$0.000 |
|
Career Pathways |
$5.000 |
$0.000 |
$0.750 |
$0.750 |
|
Caretaker Relative/Kinship |
$0.250 |
$0.000 |
$0.051 |
$0.051 |
|
Centro of Oneida |
$0.000 |
$0.025 |
$0.025 |
$0.000 |
|
Child Care Facilitated Enrollment |
$0.000 |
$0.000 |
$1.265 |
$1.265 |
|
Child Care SUNY/CUNY |
$1.643 |
$0.334 |
$0.334 |
$0.000 |
|
Community Reinvestment/Alternatives to Det. |
$0.000 |
$0.000 |
$1.950 |
$1.950 |
|
Community Solutions for Transportation |
$0.000 |
$0.112 |
$0.112 |
$0.000 |
|
Displaced Homemakers Program |
$1.605 |
$0.546 |
$0.546 |
$0.000 |
|
Educational Resources |
$1.250 |
$0.000 |
$0.250 |
$0.250 |
|
Emergency Homeless Needs |
$0.125 |
$0.176 |
$0.500 |
$0.324 |
|
Food Pantry Initiative |
|
|
$0.250 |
$0.250 |
|
Non-Residential Domestic Violence |
$1.449 |
$0.510 |
$1.210 |
$0.700 |
|
Nurse Family Partnership* |
$2.000 |
$0.000 |
$2.000 |
$2.000 |
|
Preventive Services |
$6.000 |
$0.610 |
$0.610 |
$0.000 |
|
Public Assistance Grant |
|
|
|
$12.000 |
|
Refugee Resettlement** |
$0.500 |
$0.102 |
$0.102 |
$0.000 |
|
Rochester Genesee Regional Transportation Authority |
$0.500 |
$0.082 |
$0.082 |
$0.000 |
|
Settlement Houses |
$1.000 |
$0.500 |
$1.000 |
$0.500 |
|
Strengthening Families through Stronger Fathers |
$0.000 |
$0.200 |
$0.200 |
$0.000 |
|
Wage Subsidy Program |
$0.409 |
$0.950 |
$0.950 |
$0.000 |
|
Wheels for Work |
$0.000 |
$0.144 |
$0.144 |
$0.000 |
|
Total |
|
|
|
$25.590 |
*Nurse Family Partnership is funded with $2 million in TANF funds and
$.5 million in DOH funding.
** Refugee Resettlement funding is transferred to the new Office of New
Americans in the State Dept.
***Public Assistance Grant increase total for FY13 is $16 million ($12
million TANF and $4 million general funds).
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH (DOH)
Health Insurance Exchange
The
Health Insurance Exchange that New York State is required to set up under
federal health care reforms to expand coverage did not make it into the final
budget agreement. The Governor will now have to issue an Executive Order
to create an Exchange or face having the federal government develop a plan for
New York.
MRT Supportive Housing Development
Program
The
budget establishes and funds a new Supportive Housing Development Program,
recommended by the Medicaid Redesign Team (MRT) that will provide service
funding, rent subsidies and capital dollars to create supportive housing for
high-cost Medicaid recipients. The new fund will be supported with $60 million in
State general funds this year, and $75 million State general funds in each of
the following two years, with funding originating in the NYS Department of
Health, to be distributed to HCR, OTDA, OMH, OASAS, OPWDD and the DOH AIDS
Institute. To read more about this important new investment see the Supportive
Housing Network’s summary at: http://shnny.org/budget-policy/state/
State Relief for
Local Medicaid Expenses
The budget approves a
state takeover of growth in the local share of Medicaid costs and implements a
phased takeover of local government Medicaid administration expenses. In
2013-14, local government Medicaid growth will be reduced to two percent, and
then reduced by an additional one percent annually over the subsequent two
years so that in 2015-16, counties and New York City will no longer have to
contribute toward the growth of Medicaid expenses. The takeover of the three
percent Medicaid growth factor is expected to save counties and New York City
$1.2 billion over five state fiscal years.
Elderly Pharmaceutical Insurance
Coverage (EPIC)
The budget restores $30.6 million to
EPIC for drugs on a participant's Part D formulary during the initial coverage
and catastrophic phases of Medicare Part D. Participants, instead of paying the
Part D co-payment which is a percentage of a drug's cost, will only be
responsible for the EPIC co-payment that will be no higher than $20.
Early Intervention
The final budget rejects proposed Child
Health Plus insurance coverage for the Early Intervention program and
eliminates a $1.2 million appropriation for this purpose. The FY13 budget also streamlines the Early Intervention
program with administrative functions, including paying claims and contract
authority, assumed by the Department of Health to provide additional mandate
relief to counties. It also eliminates the proposal to reduce payments by two
percent. To read more, see the Assembly
Majority's Conference Committee Summary for the 2012-2013 budget (PDF p 65 of 110):
http://assembly.state.ny.us/Reports/WAM/2012conf_comm/2012conf_comte_summary.pdf
Additional Medicaid Redesign Changes
To see more about the many Medicaid Redesign
proposals that have been included in the FY13 budget, please go to:
DOH’s 2012-13 Enacted Budget Webinar Presentation - “2012-13 Enacted Budget MRT Phase II Proposals” at: http://www.health.ny.gov/health_care/medicaid/redesign/
Additional
Medicaid Redesign information can be found in the Assembly Majority's Conference Committee Summary for the 2012-2013 budget (PDF page
67-72 of 110):
http://assembly.state.ny.us/Reports/WAM/2012conf_comm/2012conf_comte_summary.pdf
OFFICE OF MENTAL HEALTH (OMH)
The FY13 budget includes the following
mental health service adjustments under OMH:
·
$3.9
million in restorations to reflect the rejection of several Article VII actions
pertaining to the Sex Offender Management Treatment Act (SOMTA).
·
$1.1
million added to reject an Executive proposal to include local correctional facilities
as appropriate institutions for incapacitated individuals awaiting trial.
·
$800,000
added for veteran’s peer-to-peer pilot programs and $500,000 for Veteran’s
Health Services.
·
$800,000
added for demonstration programs for counties impacted by facility closures in
FY12.
·
The budget restores “Prescriber Prevails;” requiring managed care
plans to automatically approve prescribers’ and patients’ medication
preferences for anti‐psychotic medications,
even if they are not on plan formularies.
·
The
budget allows the Behavioral Health Advisory Council to have joint oversight of
behavioral health services when there are duplicative requirements from OMH and
OASAS.
OFFICE FOR PEOPLE WITH
DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES (OPWDD)
The FY13 budget includes the following
developmental disability service adjustments under OPWDD:
·
$250,000
for Statewide Regional Centers for Autism Spectrum Disorders, and provides
$50,000 for the Epilepsy Foundation of Northeastern New York.
·
The
enacted budget rejects the proposal to allow OPWDD to establish Medicaid waiver
pilot programs without a competitive process.
STATE OFFICE FOR THE AGING (SOFA)
|
SOFA
Programs (in
millions) |
FY11 Total Budget Amount |
FY12 Total Budget Amount |
FY13 Total Budget Amount |
FY13 Cut/Add |
|
Naturally Occurring Retirement Communities (NORCs) and
Neighborhood NORCs* |
$4.054 |
$4.054 |
$4.054 |
$0.000 |
|
Community Services for the Elderly (CSE)** |
$15.312 |
$15.312 |
$15.368 |
$0.056 |
|
Expanded In-home Services for the Elderly (EISEP)** |
$46.035 |
$46.035 |
$46.845 |
$0.809 |
|
Regional Caregiver Centers of Excellence |
$0.230 |
$0.115 |
$0.000 |
-$0.115 |
|
Total |
|
|
|
$0.750 |
*NORCs and NNORCs each received restorations of $2.027M. The
Governor had proposed to reduce funding by $229,000 each.
**Funding was added to both
CSE and EISEP to make up for funding losses due to census population changes.
Division of Veteran’s Affairs (DVA)
The Legislature provided $150,000 in
additional support under the Veterans Counseling Services Program to restore
support for the following programs:
|
DVA Programs (in millions) |
FY13 Adds |
|
NY Veterans of Foreign
Wars |
$0.075 |
|
NY Veterans of Foreign
Wars - Buffalo Office |
$0.050 |
|
Vietnam Veterans NYS
Council |
$0.025 |
|
Total |
$0.150 |
Division of Housing and Community Renewal
Neighborhood and Rural Preservation Programs
The enacted budget restored and increased funding for the
Neighborhood Preservation Program (NPP) and the Rural Preservation Program
(RPP), from $8.48 million to $10 million and from $3.54 million to $4.2
million, respectively. NPP and RPP promote and preserve housing for low- and
moderate- income individuals by providing planning and administrative funds to
community-based nonprofit corporations known as Neighborhood and Rural
Preservation Companies.
Office of New Americans
The FY13 budget establishes an Office of New Americans within the Department of
State to support efforts to assist legal permanent residents to better
participate in the state's economy and civic life. The Office of New Americans
will focus on expanding access to English language education services,
promoting U.S. citizenship and civic involvement, and expanding business
opportunities for new American business owners.
DIVISION OF CRIMINAL
JUSTICE SERVICES (DCJS)
The FY13 budget includes the following justice service
adjustments under DCJS:
·
More
flexibility for funding alternatives to incarceration and re-entry programs by
allowing a $3.1 million appropriation allocated for Re-entry Task Forces to
also be available for any program that helps to reduce the risk of re-offending.
·
$1.2 million increase for
alternatives to incarceration programs.
·
Restoration of support for civil and criminal legal
services programs, including domestic violence legal services, in the amount of
$3.9 million with receipts from the Legal Services Assistance Fund and $1.218
million from the Criminal Justice Improvement Account.
·
$450,000 for legal services for
immigrant students and families.
·
$200,000
in funding to support not-for-profit programs that provide postsecondary
educational programs in prison.
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES
Foreclosure
Relief Unit
The
budget provides $9 million for the continuation of mortgage foreclosure
counseling services through Homes and Community Renewal, with additional services
financed with proceeds of the National Mortgage Servicing Settlement Agreement.
In addition, the Department of Financial Services will establish a new
Foreclosure Relief Unit to provide counseling and mediation services to help
New Yorkers stay in their homes.
Thanks to Chris Winward for this analysis.